The NBA has always had its headliners. The MVPs, the scoring champs, the franchise faces, the dudes whose names get stamped on commercials, signature shoes, and “best player in the league” debates. But that’s never been the whole story. Basketball history is also built on the killers who didn’t always get the biggest spotlight — the steady hands, matchup nightmares, elite connectors, defensive monsters, and microwave scorers who kept great teams afloat when they weren’t the first name on the marquee.
That’s why the “underrated” conversation always hits different in the NBA. Not everybody can be a No. 1 option, but that doesn’t mean everybody else is regular. Some players were asked to do the dirty work. Some had to sacrifice shots to fit around stars. Some got overshadowed because they played in loaded eras, while others were so fundamentally sound that people mistook consistency for being “just solid.” Whole time, they were making winning plays, stacking accolades, and shaping games in ways box-score watchers didn’t always fully appreciate.
And that’s really what makes this kind of list fun. We’re not talking about random good players. We’re talking about guys who could hoop for real, dudes whose careers deserve more love when basketball history gets discussed. Some were champions. Some were specialists so elite that teams had to build around what they did. Some were walking buckets or floor generals who somehow slipped through the cracks because they never got the same media push as flashier stars.
Love Entertainment? Get more! Join the The Box Richmond - 99.5 / 102.7 Newsletter
So with that in mind, here are (in no particular order) 12 of the most underrated players in NBA history — a mix of glue guys, stars who don’t get called stars enough, and straight-up hoopers whose impact deserves a louder conversation.
1. Andre Miller (1999-2016)
Andre Miller played like somebody’s old head uncle at the park and still kept cooking NVA athletes for 17 years. He wasn’t flashy, didn’t rely on elite athleticism, and didn’t have the kind of game that made highlight reels every night — but he could run an offense in his sleep and finished as one of the most productive passers of his time. The reason he belongs here is simple: people respected him, but history still doesn’t talk enough about how rare it is to be that steady, that smart, and that durable for that long.
2. Ben Wallace (1996-2012)
Ben Wallace is a Hall of Famer, so calling him underrated might sound wild at first, but hear it out: even with all the accolades, he still doesn’t always get mentioned with the all-time great defenders the way he should. A four-time Defensive Player of the Year who anchored a championship team and made offense miserable for elite bigs deserves way more reverence in everyday basketball talk. He wasn’t putting up 25 a night, but his impact was superstar-level where it mattered — protecting the rim, rebounding everything, and setting the identity for one of the nastiest defenses the league has seen.
3. Detlef Schrempf (1985-2001)
Detlef was ahead of his time in many ways. A skilled 6-foot-10 forward who could shoot, pass, and score efficiently, he gave teams a level of spacing and versatility that would be worshipped in today’s game. Three All-Star selections, an All-NBA nod, and two Sixth Man awards show he got respect in his day, but he still feels under-discussed now when people map the lineage of big wings who could really play.
4. Jamal Crawford (2000-2020)
Lou Williams gets a lot of love in the instant-offense convo, but Jamal Crawford was the patron saint of getting a bucket off the bench. Three Sixth Man of the Year awards tell part of the story, but not the whole thing — because his real gift was changing the temperature of a game with pure shot-making and playground creativity. He made tough scoring look casual, and for a whole generation of fans, he was one of the coldest one-on-one artists the league had to offer.
5. Jrue Holiday (2009-Present)
Jrue is one of those players hoop heads adore way more than casual fans do, and that says everything. He has been a two-way problem for more than a decade, made multiple All-Defensive teams, won two titles, and built a reputation as one of the toughest guard assignments in the league on both ends of the floor. Because he’s rarely been the loudest personality or the top scorer, a lot of people still talk about him like he’s “just a really good role player,” when in reality, he’s been one of the most complete guards of his era.
6. Lamar Odom (1999-2014)
Lamar was basically a jumbo do-everything forward before the league fully leaned into positionless basketball. At 6-foot-10, he could rebound, push the break, pass, handle, and slide between frontcourt spots without making the game feel clunky. Playing next to Kobe definitely helped him win, but it also made some folks overlook how uniquely gifted he was; he wasn’t just a side piece on title teams, he was a matchup problem whose versatility would probably be even more appreciated in today’s NBA.
7. Mark Price (1986-1998)
Before the league fully embraced small guards bombing threes off skill and precision, Mark Price was already putting on a clinic. He made four All-Star teams, four All-NBA teams, joined the 50-40-90 club, and built a reputation as one of the cleanest offensive guards of his time. Injuries and the fact that those Cleveland teams never broke all the way through have made him a little too easy for history to overlook, but as a scorer-playmaker-shooter package, he was elite.
8. Maurice Cheeks (1978-1993)
Maurice Cheeks is the kind of player winning teams dream about and modern discourse forgets to hype. He was a four-time All-Star, a champion, a terrific defender, and one of the best steady-hand point guards of the 1980s. Because he wasn’t as flashy as some of the bigger names from that era, he can get skipped over in all-time point guard talks, but his résumé and impact say he should be brought up way more often.
9. Michael Cooper (1978-1990)
Michael Cooper is one of the best examples of why scoring alone can’t measure impact. He was the defensive heartbeat for Showtime, made eight All-Defensive teams, won Defensive Player of the Year, and helped the Lakers win five championships. Since he wasn’t the face of that dynasty — and played next to Magic and Kareem — his brilliance can get lost, but every great team needs somebody like him, and very few have ever done that job better.
10. Rod Strickland (1988-2005)
Rod Strickland was filthy, plain and simple. His handle, paint touches, and ability to finish among bigs made him one of the craftiest guards of the 1990s, and he even led the league in assists in 1997-98. But because he bounced around a bit and never got the playoff spotlight that some other point guards did, his name doesn’t come up nearly enough when folks talk about the best pure table-setters of that era.
11. Sleepy Floyd (1982-1995)
Sleepy Floyd is one of those names younger fans don’t bring up enough, but real basketball history has him tucked in some serious chapters. He was an All-Star, had multiple big scoring seasons, and authored one of the most unforgettable playoff explosions ever with his 51-point game against the Lakers in 1987. Because he played in an era stacked with legendary guards, his name can get buried, but he absolutely deserves a seat in the underrated bucket.
12. Toni Kukoč
Being on the Jordan-Pippen Bulls was both a blessing and a curse for Toni Kukoč’s legacy. He won three rings and a Sixth Man award, but because he played alongside two all-time icons, people sometimes reduce him to just another supporting role instead of recognizing how advanced his skill set really was. A 6-foot-11 playmaker with vision, shot creation, and an international pedigree like that was not normal, and his game translated beautifully to the NBA.
